Suppose , and are integers and . Which of these statements is false?
Solution
We are given that and four statements. We could simply pick negative values for , , and and check the four statements. But, if we like, we can use fancy reasoning. Have a look:
Let’s cancel , which we are allowed to do because is not zero. But is negative, so the cancellation switches the direction of the inequality. We get . This we were given. This one is true.
Again let’s cancel the common factor () and switch the direction of the inequality. We get . Whoa Nellie! We were given . This must be the false one.
Here we may subtract the common addend (). This does not require we switch the direction of the inequality. We get which we were given. This one is true.
Add to both sides and we get , which we were given. This one is true.